This is my research on setermining which ESR meter i should buy.
There is a series resistor inside capacitor, using 100kHz to remove the impedance 1/(2*pi*F*C), the impedance become small, and we can then measure the true series resistor value.
A bad E-capacitor will have larger ESR and create large ripple rather than filtering noise. Normally, a big capacitor is larger than 3 ohm.
Using this theory, we can measure the capacitor is bad/ damaged or good in condition.
Because our ESR meter only applies less than 15mV DC or peak to peak on a good capacitor, as a result we can use it as in circuit test. Because this low testing voltage, it cannot turn on the semiconductor inside a circuit under testing.
During repairing TV, LCD, Audio board, etc. we can in circuit testing the capacitor is good or not.
Firstly, what is an ESR Meter? An ESR Meter is used to measure the internal resistance of a capacitor. This feature allows you to measure a capacitor in-circuit and determine if it is faulty by its resistance. This make diagnosis consumer electronics much easier because other wise to measure a capacitor you would have to remove it from the circuit which involves desoldering, test it and then resolder it back into the circuit if not faulty. This process will have to continue for all the capacitors on the board. With an ESR Meter you can check capcacitors in moments.
A 100KHz sine wave is pushed through the capacitor at such a low voltage that no components are triggered (opened or closed) and the sine wave is measured. From this you can determine the internal resistance of a capacitor. This outcome is determined by several variables of the capacitor:
As a rule of thumb, if the internal resistance is above 1Ω (ohm), the capacitor is faulty. This is definately the case in most consumer electronics.
This was a very tricky thing to find out. There are alsorts of devices that says they measure ESR. Many are not practical, acurate or cheap. Which ones have protection, which are easy to use and so on. I have research all the main ones you will; come across and i have made a little pros and cons of each one. I also at the bottom have put my recommendation and why. This will be the one i actually bought and used.
Pros
Cons
During my research i cam across the following different brands of ESR meter
Misc
Model | Price | Notes | URL |
VICHY VC6243+ 3.0" LCD LC Digital Capacitance Meter / Secohmmeter / Henrymeter - Deep Grey + Orange | 18.63 | Measure capacitance and inductance - With capacitor discharge protection - Power dissipation: Quiescent current approx. 4mA - Full protect function, capacitor with the function of self discharge - Full protect function, capacitor with the function of self discharge | http://www.dx.com/p/vichy-vc6243-3-0-lcd-lc-digital-capacitance-meter-secohmmeter-henrymeter-deep-grey-orange-205946#.VAX30GOFn5Q |
Honeytek A6013L Capacitor Tester | $19.35 | capacitence only - Auto discharge for capacitors below 1000V LSI-circuit provides high reliability and durability |
http://www.amazon.com/Honeytek-A6013L-Capacitor-Tester/dp/B0036FQ3FW/ref=pd_cp_hi_1 |
A6013L LCD Capacitance Capacitor Meter Tester Multimeter from 20mF to 200pF FUS | 10.17 | same as honeytek | http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/A6013L-LCD-Capacitance-Capacitor-Meter-Tester-Multimeter-from-20mF-to-200pF-FUS-/281308159501?pt=UK_BOI_Electrical_Test_Measurement_Equipment_ET&hash=item417f45de0d |
honeytek | 10.36 | honeytek on ebay | http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/A6013L-LCD-Capacitance-Capacitor-Meter-Tester-Multimeter-20mF-To-200pF-/281158881329?pt=UK_Sound_Vision_Other&hash=item4176601031 |
honeytek | 9.76 | honeytek on ebay | http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/291224408876 |
blue esr | |||
atlas peak esr70 | 100 | can measure up to 40 ohms - has inbuilt protection - can discharge caps up to 50V - you have to buy extra probes at £25 | |
UNI-T UT612 LCR Meter | 100 | this is an LCR but does ESR aswell | http://www.tester.co.uk/uni-t-ut612-lcr-meter - |
MESR-100 V2 | 35 | esr tester only - has diodes for charge protection which is very basic and means you cannot esr batteries | |
VICHY DM4070 3" LCD 1/2 Digital Handheld LCR Multimeter - Deep Grey + Orange | 25 | Measure capacitance and inductance - With capacitor discharge protection - Full protect function, capacitor with the function of self discharge - Full protect function, capacitor with the function of self discharge | http://www.dx.com/p/vichy-dm4070-3-lcd-1-2-digital-handheld-lcr-multimeter-deep-grey-orange-205159#.VAYgb2OFn5R |
VICHY VC9808+ | $40 | Vichy VC9808+ Manual Range Digital Multimeter Inductance 3 1/2 Data hold Peak Value DCV DCA Resistance Capacitance Test | http://www.amazon.com/VC9808-Multimeter-Inductance-Resistance-Capacitance/dp/B00J3NNG7E/ref=pd_sim_sbs_hi_2?ie=UTF8&refRID=011NXVS6D6MT352VWGK6 |
VICHY VC6013 Digital 3.0" LCD Capacitance Multimeter - Grey + Orange (1 x 6F22) | 14 | capacitence with discharge and protection | http://www.dx.com/p/vichy-vc6013-digital-3-0-lcd-capacitance-inductance-multimeter-grey-orange-1-x-6f22-201685#.VAX3xWOFn5Q |
ebay cheap 8.99 | you can add your own probes on to them | ||
fluke | |||
VC6013 digital capacitor meter 200pf to 20mF discharge | 20 | .full protect function, capacitor with the function of self discharge; | http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/300637212088?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT |
honeytek | 56 | auto discharge | http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/200975497949?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT |
agilent 1730c | they seem to have better input protection |
Questions
For 0.25MM Solder Ball (1 pcs)
P4933007
For 0.30MM Solder Ball (11 pcs)
0.30 universal stencil(pitch=0.58MM)
Intel 82801 IUX (AM828001IUX)
SIRF AT640
MTK MT6226/8226
INFINEON TECH PMB7850
850AZYL
Intel BD 82HM65
L-FW643E-2 new
LFXP2-5E new
1131S2P1X2( for tablet)
IR 7807A779(7807ZTR chip)
For 0.35MM Solder Ball (8 pcs)
0.35 universal stencil(pitch=0.65MM)
Intel AC82GS45/ SLB92/ E26593/82HM57/AC82GS965
Intel AF82US15W SLGFQ
Intel AC80566/533
Intel BD82HM55/BD82GM55(BD82HM550)
330-FBGA-1414(new add)
Intel 82801HUB
SRO4S-CPU
For 0.4MM Solder Ball (6 pcs)
0.40 universal stencil(pitch=0.7MM)
Intel BD82P55
Intel BD82H61
Intel I7-620M
NV MCP79U-B2 /nVIDIA GeForce 9400M G(MCP79U)
For 0.45MM Solder Ball (20 pcs)
0.45 universal stencil(pitch=0.78MM)
Memory DDR1
Memory DDR2
Memory DDR2-2
Memory DDR2-3
Memory DDR3 (can be used XBOX CACHE 505 code)
Memory DDR5
Intel AC82PM45/'AC82GM45//82GL40//AC88CTPM(82PM45//GM45
Intel AC82P45/AC82P43(82P45) //G41
Intel CG82NM10/SLGXX
PVC0019 (PUC-0019)
L110IA07
F2117LP
SR071
Memory DDR3-2
Memory DDR3-3
Memory DDR3-4 KF
18A16GW
NV T20L-H-A1
CC-16ALQDW
For 0.5MM Solder Ball (66 pcs)
0.5 universal stencil(pitch=0.8MM)
ATI 1100//1150//AMD /216MQA6AVA12FG /038SSP /0738SSP RS485M//RS485MC //RS690M
ATI 21514//M64-M 216PVAVA12FG///215CDABKA15FG//X2600PRO//M74-M//216-0707009 universal
ATI 21515//216-0707011//M72-S//M82-S A11//ATI0909SSP//216-0707001/M64-S
ATI 215-0669065
ATI 215-0708003// 215-0308003//0803SSP Universal
ATI 215-0719090//216-0728014
ATI 215-0758000
ATI 215-0735003
ATI 216-0728018/Universal ATI 216-0708020//ATI 215-0725018/216-0728020/ATI -HD4570//0725013//0725007/
ATI 218-0697010/218-0697014/218-0792001
ATI 700M//ATI200M//RC415MD//RC415M/216DCP5ALA11FG(ATI X700/64M M26-CSP64 216CZGAKA13FH)
ATI RS800ME//RS600ME(RS600ME 216MEP6CLA14FG)
ATI IXP600//SB600(XP600)
ATI SB700/RD700/RD780//218S7EBLA12FG//216-0674026//216-0674022//AMDIGP
ATI IXP460
ATI E350
ATI X1300-216PQAKA13FG;Universal M52-P 216PNAKA13FG
ATI M64-M
ATI AMD-CPU 0?5
ATI RS485M/(1150 RS485M 216MSA4ALA12FG) 0.5
ATI 215-0807018
AMD AND-X2-CPU
NV MCP67MV-A2//MCP67M-A2 MCP67D-A3/MCP77MV-A2//MCP87
NV MCP7A-P-B1(MCP7A-P-A1//MCP79S//MCP79M)MCP79MXT-B2
NV NF-6100-430(NF-6100-N-A2//8200//8400//8600)NF-G6100-N-A2
NV NF-200-SL1-A2//BR04-300-A2(NF200-5LI-A2 )
NV NF-6801-SL1-N-A2 (NF-6801-SL1)
NV NF-7150-6301-A2 (NF-7150-630I-A2)NF7050//7100//7150
NV GFGO7400-N-A3//GFGO7200//7300//6200AGP//G84(G86)-630-A2//G86-631-A2//G86-620-A2//G86-621-A2
NV GF104-325-A1
NV G94-300-A1//G94-210-A1
NV G96-600-A1//GT215-450-A2(G96-630-A1 /C1 G96-750-A1 G96-632-C1)Universal G96-309-B1(important)
NV G200-103-B3(G200-103-B1)
NV GF 106-250-KA-A1
NV NF790IU-SLI-N-B1
NV GF100-030-A3
NV BR03-N-A3
NV NF8200 (GF8200-A-A2)
NV N12P-Q3-A1 0?5
NV G96-309-A1
NV G86-631-A2 (new) 0.5
Intel 965(LE82965//82P965//82P31 )G31
Intel QG 82945P//82945GC
Intel QG 82945PM( QG945GM//QG945PM )945GM//QG82945GM
Intel QG 82945GMS (82945GMS/945GMS)
Intel NQ82915GMS (QG 82915GMS)915GMS
Intel LE82PM965//LE82GM965(965GM/PM)
Intel LGA1155
Intel LGA1156
Intel N475CPU
Intel E5099(E50999 chip)
VIA MSPII ///VX800U
ATHEROS AR2313A-001
ATHEROS AR2414A-001
RAYLIN RT2571W(Ralink2571 chip/RT2573)
Conexant CX82310-14
ST STi7162
S5C2410H11
S5C2410H
NSC-NATIONAL SEMI 1822-0727
INGENIC 4732HXF(JZ4732HXF-D0)
TI 5416GGU(DVC5416GGU)
TI TMS320DM642A2DK(new add)
XILINX FG900(XCV600E-FG900 )
CC-06AP8LW(new add)
For 0.6MM Solder Ball (114 pcs)
NV GF-GO6200/7200/7300/7400/7600/G84-630-A2/G86-730-A2/G86-771-A2
NV G80-100-K1-A2 (G80-100-K1)/G80-300-A2/8800GTX
NV GO5200
NV GO6800-B1 (GO 6800-BI)GO7800//GO7900
NV 4200GO(GO4200)
NV NF-4N-A3//NF4-A3(NF4-N-A3)
NV NF-430-N-A3//NF-410-N-A3
NV NF550/NF570
NV NF-G6150-N-A2/NF-G6100-N-A2//NF-6100-A2//SPP-100-N-A2Universal(NF-GO6100/6150)
NV NF-GO150
NV 420GO
NV MX440
NV HSI-A4
NV NF 250(NF32-50)/NFORCE3 250GB
NV FXGO5200(FGO5200)
NV FX5700
NV FX5900//GO6800LE
NV "NV MCP89M2-A2/MCP89M-ENG-A2?
(new) 0.60"
NV GO5700 (FX-GO5700 0.6
NV NF4-SL1-SPP
NV GO 6800/6600
ATI 215-0718020
ATI 215RGMDKA13FG
ATI 218BAPAGA12F
ATI 200M//RS480M//216MPA4AKA22//M64-P
ATI 7500 M7/9000-CSP32 216QTCGBGA13 216QTCFBGA13
ATI 9000 64M//M9-CSP64//216T9NGBGA13FHG
ATI 9000 IGP
ATI 9100 IGP
ATI 9200//9600//9700//X300//X600//X700
ATI 9600-T2
ATI M6-C16(K6-C16)
ATI IXP400//IXP450
ATI X1600/X1650/RV516//X1300//X700//X1400/X1700//M52-P
ATI X1800
ATI R360
ATI RC410MB//AT1200MUniversal
ATI R480 (215RBHAGA11//215RBPAGA11FF)
AMD 215-0716050
VIA CLE266
VIA C7-M
VIA CX700M
VIA VT8235M
VIA VT8235//VT8237//VT8237A
VIA VT8237R (8237R)
VIA VT8237S
VIA VT8251
VIA VX700
VIA P4M898
VIA P4M890/900//CN896//VN896
VIA PN800
VIA K8M890
VIA VT82037R(new)0.6
SIS 307ELV(307)
SIS 648FX
SIS 649
SIS 655FX
SIS 661FX (M661MX M661GX)
SIS 662
SIS 671//SIS671DX/SIS672
SIS 756
SIS 964L(964)
SIS 965L(965)
SIS 968
Intel N270-1.60GHZ/512/533- SLB73//AU80586GE025D
Intel 1828-0206//1825-0206//1825-0220
Intel 775CPU
Intel 82801HB(80001HB)
Intel 82801GBM//82801GR//82801GB// NH82801GHM
Intel 82801HBM//82801IBM//NH82801HEM
Intel 82801IB// 82801IR//82801IO//82801JIB
Intel 82801FBM
Intel 82801BA
Intel 82915P (QG82915P //NG82915G)
Intel 989
Intel QG5000P (QG500P//QC5000P)
Intel 915PM/915GM (QG82915PM//GM)82915PM
Intel X38 (AC82X38)
Intel X58 (AC82X58)
Intel RC82540EM
Intel RG82865PE (865PE)
Intel LGA1366 (IGA1366)
BROADCOM BCM5464
BROADCOM BCM21000
BROADCOM BCM56639(DCM56639)
BROADCOM BCM6368UKPBG
CB6849
CIZB0003716 (C1ZBZ0003716)
MTK MT5362BLG
MTK MT5363
MTK MT5388
MTK MT8202AG
ARM MT8520
M1573 A1 (M1573 R1)
M1697-AIB
FREESCAD MPC8270
PIXELWOR PW106B-10L
PIXELWOR PW218-10L
PHI SAA7117AE
TSX188-B1A02-L
62898C2
LSILOGLC 62095D2
XCI5000 676(new add)
XILINX XC3S1000
1009HAL(new add)
Agilent 28V3-0001 KF
S4LHP01 KF
1822-0724 KF
L7D2053 KF
HP 1825-0184 KF
ST X380
0.6(0.9pitch=)(pitch=0.9mm) Universal Stencil
0.6(1.0pitch=)(pitch=1.0mm) Universal Stencil
0.6(1.1pitch=)(pitch=1.1mm) Universal Stencil
For 0.76MM Solder Ball (50 pcs)
0.76 universal stencil (pitch=1.27)
ATI 216-PSZBFA22H\320M/330M/340M/345M Universal(ATI 216PS2BFA22H)
ATI AMD SOKET SI CPU (SOSKET SI CPU)
ATI IXP150
ATI 941
ATI M1535+
ATI AM2
ATI AM3
Intel 478CPU
Intel 479/LE80539//SL6F5
Intel 754CPU
Intel 845GL/845GV
Intel 855GM//855GME
Intel 82801EB
Intel 82801AA
Intel 82801DBM/82801DB
Intel 82371EB
Intel M1671(ALIM1671BI )
Intel FW82815EP
Intel RG82875
Intel 845MP/855PM(RG845MP/855PM)
Intel 82801CAM (FW82801CAM 0.76
SIS 630E/630
SIS 630S
SIS 650
SIS 760LV
SIS 962
VIA K8M800
VIA K8T800
VIA VT82C686B
VIA VT82C694X
VIA VN800
VIA P4M800
VIA PN133 (PN133T)
VIA P4X266A
AUO AUO-024
BROADCOM BCM53242
USA/europe MCP8245RRZU400D(MCP8245//MCP8245AR)
FREESCAD MPC880
GEENSI FLI18532-LF
PANELPRO T7203
MARVELL 1825-8249
MARVELL 1825-0050
2R39741
NXP/HP 1825-0177
Z71Z46A
BROADCOM BCM3349KPBG
1825-0427 KF
HP 1825-0264 KF
320/330/340
Game Console Stencils (42pcs)
Microsoft XBOX 360CPU 0.6
Microsoft XBOX 360GPU 0.6
Microsoft XBOX 360HANA 0.6
Microsoft XBOX 360CSP(360 Southbridge) 0.6
Microsoft XBOX XCPU C-A01
Microsoft XB360AV 0.6
Sony PS3-CPU(new model) 0.6
Sony PS3-GPU(old model) 0.6
Sony CPS3 CPU BALL
Sony PS3-CXR714120/CXR714123 ( PS3-CXD714120 0.6
Sony PS3 CXD2964GB 0.6
Sony PS3 CXD2973GB//2976GB 0.6
Nintendo WII GPUAA(new model) 0.6
Nintendo WII GPU(old model) 0.6
Nintendo WII CPU(new model) 0.6
Nintendo WIICPUB 0.5
Sony CXD2949CGB 0.76
Sony CXD2972GB 0.6
Sony CXD2976GB 0.6
Sony CXD2980BGB//CXD29808 0.6
Sony CXD2992GB 0.6
Sony CXD7203-15 0.76
Sony CXD9209GB 0.6
Sony CXD9799GB (CAD9799GP) 0.76
Sony CXD9833GB 0.76
Sony CXD1876 (CXD1876-102GG)/new add 0.35
Sony CXD2981GB
PSP PSP-1/5209 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-2/2975 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-3 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-4 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PS3-5CPU (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-6 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-7 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP3-1 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-MB44C018A (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-LR38807 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP 833KM3E (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP L8GV7657 (0.3mm Soler Ball)
PSP PSP-Z7-201A(PSP-27-201A) (0.6mm Soler Ball)
Sony CXD929GB KF
PSP PS3-2 KF
Universal Stencils (0.25-0.76MM--18pcs)
0.5MM 35*35 universal stencil pitch=0.78mm
0.5MM 40*40 universal stencil 1pitch=0.8mm
0.55M universal stencil pitch= 1.02mm
0.6MM 24*24 universal stencil pitch=0.99mm
0.6MM 27*27 universal stencil pitch=0.99
0.6MM 30*30 universal stencil pitch=0.99
0.6MM 33*33 universal stencil pitch=0.99
0.6MM 41*41 universal stencil pitch=0.01
0.65MM universal stencil pitch=0.1
0.76MM30*30 universal stencil pitch=0.27
0.76MM33*33 universal stencil pitch=1.27
0.76MM34*34 universal stencil pitch=1.27
0.76MM37*37 universal stencil pitch=1.27
0.76MM 41*41 universal stencil pitch=1.27
1.00MM universal stencil pitch=1.5
0.25MM universal stencil pitch=0.5
0.30MM universal stencil pitch=0.5
0.35MM universal stencil pitch=0.6
MTK/IPHON4 (17PCS)
MTK MTK3301
MTK MTK6205
MTK MTK6217
MTK MTK6218
MTK MTK6219
MTK MTK6223
MTK MTK6225
MTK MTK6226
MTK MTK6228
MTK MTK6230
MTK MTK6231
MTK MTK6235
MTK MTK6238
MTK MTK6318
MTK MTK6325
MTK MTK6600
MTK IPHON4-CPU
Q: What is the real difference between using the jig reball method and direct heating other than the large difference in cost?
A: The direct heat stencils don't last as long as the 90mm, if you're not extremely careful with them then they can last as little as 1-2 reballs before they need replacing. The 90mm stencils will never have to be replaced.
I have finally got around to sorting out the rest of the kit I need. But I need to questions answering and then it might be quicker if I could ring you.
Questions
I want to buy stencils and a station so I can do most chips without having to buy more stencils and there are/were a few sellers on ebay selling 500+ piece sets, I know you have mentions that you do not have such sets but could build one.
Answers From Karl (bgamods)
So far this is my wishlist
What I currently have
Description
This is our solder remover squeegee fitted to an aluminium handle, and includes an extra silicone squeegee.
After lifting a BGA from a PCB, the solder is completely liquidus and it is the right time to simply, squeegee the molten solder onto a clean area of the PCB to avoid using solder wick and soldering iron to remove the old solder.
This method is very quick and is the gentlest by far, avoiding solder mask damage which is often the case when using the abrasive method with solder wick and soldering iron.
what temperature should you use it to remove leaded solder?
For removing leaded solder, it is usually necessary to use around 230 deg C.
what temperature should you use it to remove lead-free solder?
For removing lead-free solder you will need to use around 245 deg C.
what is the life expectancy of the squeegy, are there signs of wearing out?
There is no limit to the life expectancy in my view. I hope I will live long enough to outlast mine.
These are my notes on BGA reflowing and some electronic notes
How to build a profile (from BGAMods Forum)
Q: what way the do you create a profile with a three zone machine ? (jaymbyrne)
A: The principal is still exactly the same as i never run an actual profile with the lower HR. i just have it set to the same temp as the lower IR and have it running constant so both lower IR and HR should heat at the same rate to give a nice even preheat. ive posted an example profile for ivan but ill do a quick guide tomorrow AM and get it upped in this section.(bgamods) JonnuGunz has a better method.
For the ball re-attach (i think this is johhnygunz advice)
- 1 profile 1.0/190/1000 and just watches them manually (this is for lead free)
- most will reattach from 80c but when using the machine cold it can go all the way up to 180/190
- note all bottom heaters are set to off HR (hr = heat radiation ?)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teFwYPRgp5s
put the probe right next to the chip but not touching it
using RMA 218-kingbo flux for putting around the rim of the chip before lifting, he is quite liberal, bead all the way around it
multimeter is used for TC display
14:33
17.03
18.57
21.15
21.25
23.55
30.33
38.00
40.11
51.25
52.30
56.23
58.29
101.32
103.30
107.28
108.18
110.50
115.00
115.72
117.18
120.16
Notes From Comments
These are my questions about the Blackjack BK6000 SMD rework station and the answers from Circuit Specialists (Brett).
I've no experience of the Hakko 808, so it's difficult for me to provide any comparison.
What I can tell you is that both the BK 6050 and BK 6000 are good stations. Both have a 70W output on the desoldering side, so should be more than capable of doing the job.
Sorry I can't give you any more insight into the station against the hand-held solution.
I would imagine that a pistol backed by a station would have more power, but again with no direct comparison to make in terms of the items we stock (station vs handheld), but I stress that I am speculating rather than speaking from a position of having tested handheld units.
Best regards,
Brett
I only noticed after you mentioned about the 6000 having cartridge type heating and the 6050 having sheath.
Thermal Transfer Pads are used to bridge the gap between Heatsinks and Chips where heat paste will not bridge the gap, they are those blue sticky pads. A usual place to find these is in a laptop on the GPU between it and the heatsink. There are several sizes 0.5mm,1.0mm, 1.5mm, 2.0mm and 3.0mm. There might be other sizes but these are the main ones. For my research so far it looks like 1.5mm is the one most used.
These should all be non-conductive. I have ordered a Grey one and had White arrived and the guy said they were the same. Also a small note that they have different values of heat transfer, for the most part this should not be a problem for general laptop repairs.
Thermal Transfer Pads are also known as:
I have bought from:
Notes
When configuring a joomla's website email settings (or other email app) you can add a clients email address as the 'From email' (joomla admin / System / Global Configuration / Server / From email ) and usually when you do this, joomla sends the email as if their email had sent it, and then client receives it. With yahoo this does not happen
Yahoo will not accept email from other email servers proporting to be yahoo. They enforce SPF and so i cannot spoof an email address to send email yahoo or possibly other email address.
Read this from yahoo - Help Central | - SLN7253 - Error "554 5.7.9: Message not accepted for policy reasons" when sending email to Yahoo
This might also apply to other email companies ie. Google and Bing, if not now probably shortly.
The fix is to set the 'Mail From' with valid email address on your domain. You can then set an alternative reply address to accomodate for cutomers who use yahoo/bing/google email accounts exclusively. The email will come from the email from their domain but if you set the 'subject' with something like 'website enquiry' you can set an antispam rule to prevent the email getting filed in their junk folder.
Notes for cPanel
Joomla
(joomla admin / system /global configuration / server / mail settings)
JSN Uniform (additional)
These step are not require for the email to work but allow the reply option to work as intended
Port | Use | |
25 | smtp, can run plain text email and starttls | |
26 | smtp, can run plain text email and starttls, also used by email companies when port 25 is blocked | |
110 | pop3 plain text | |
143 | imap plain text | |
465 | smtp Enforced SSL/TLS | |
587 | smtp can run plain text email and starttls - supposed to be the standard port for enforced TLS encyption. cPanel allows StartTLS and plain text on this port by default. | |
993 | pop3 secure (SSL/TLS) | |
995 | imap secure (SSL/TLS) | |
2525 | smtp unofficial alternative |
* starttls allows a plain text session to upgrade to TLS
This trick can be used for diagnosing your email connection issues. There are more complicated featurees can be typed but are not covered here.
The following commands need to be typed in exactly and then followed by pressing the return key. Yhe session will not handle deletions, if you perform a deletions you will need to start again.
telnet testserver-com.mail.eo.outlook.com 25 ehlo testserver.com mail from: bob@builder.co.uk rcpt to: info@testserver.com
This is a stupid feature that cannot be turned off so you have to use one f the following solutions and Pasting a pic in an HTML composed messaged will call the Photo-Email option.
This is my prefered option and does not require any loggin in.
I did not managed to get this to work
That option(in WLM Version 2009/Build 14.x) is only present if signed on with a Live ID and no longer available in WLM Version 2011/Build 15.x
In Version 2011...
Windows Mail button(first item on Ribbon Menu)/Options/Mail/Compose
Thereafter choose Email Message instead of Photo Email for the three available options
Note: In Version 2011...Photo email creates an album with included photos and uploads to the signed on Live ID's SkyDrive(if not signed on, the user will be prompted to sign on with a Live ID to Windows Live). The Live ID does not have to be the sending email account. (i.e. Photo email pictures are no longer uploaded to a generic Msft server, they are uploaded to the user's Live ID's SkyDrive)
This method of bypassing Skydrive works, it is the one I use all the time.
but it requires you to log in.